# Review rubric: a useful, checkable campaign brief

Fictional practice exercise. This rubric records observable checks; it does not score competence, certify an AI system or approve a real workflow.

Use one status per check: supported by the artifact; needs correction; not yet checked. Add the location of the evidence and any correction. Do not use an overall score to offset a material failure. This is the learner checklist and contains no numerical answer key. Keep review-ledger.md and reviewed-reference.md aside until you have completed your first review against the sources.

## 1. Numbers
- Both Search brand rows are combined; all four source rows are accounted for.
- The five input totals reconcile to every source row: spend, impressions, clicks, purchases and attributed revenue. Record your calculated values and the supporting rows.
- Aggregate CTR, CPC, click-based CVR, CPA and ROAS follow from summed inputs and the definitions in S2. Display rounding is explained.
- The calculation ledger identifies the numerator, denominator and source for each reported rate. Averaging row or campaign percentages does not pass.

## 2. Evidence
- The brief names the period, currency, counting basis and source files.
- Its observations are traceable to S1 rows and S2 topics. It does not invent a previous period, target or cause.
- A second reviewer provides evidence and corrections, not just agreement. The final human reviewer can reproduce the key claims.

## 3. Uncertainty
- Revenue, campaign spend and profit remain distinct.
- The brief does not turn attribution into causation or assume a high observed ROAS scales with more spend.
- Missing earlier-period information, full costs and experiment evidence are stated where they affect the decision.

## 4. Action
- The brief proposes a useful next investigation, names the responsible role and states what evidence is needed.
- It stays within draft and review permissions. It does not change campaigns or claim publication approval.
- A human can explain why the next step follows from the evidence. Different defensible wording or investigations are acceptable.

## Record before calling it checked
Artifact/version:
Reviewer:
Numbers — status, evidence, correction:
Evidence — status, evidence, correction:
Uncertainty — status, evidence, correction:
Action — status, evidence, correction:
Open questions and owners:

Keep unresolved items visible. If a material check needs correction, revise the brief and inspect the affected claims again. Checking boxes without examining the artifact is not completion.
