# Review ledger

REVIEW LEDGER — fictional teaching answer

1. “Improved performance by 25%”: unsupported. S2 Scope supplies one period and no comparison. Remove the trend and request a comparable earlier-period export. No invented replacement percentage is justified.
2. “Average CTR 2.67%”: this is the rounded unweighted mean of the campaign CTRs (5%, 1%, 2%). The campaign denominators differ. Aggregate CTR is 1,500 clicks / 100,000 impressions = 1.50%. [S1 lines 2–5; S2 Rates]
3. “Overall ROAS 4.72×”: this is the rounded unweighted mean of 10, 1.666666… and 2.5. Aggregate ROAS is $3,500 attributed revenue / $1,000 spend = 3.50×. [S1 lines 2–5; S2 Rates]
4. “$2,500 profit”: $3,500 minus $1,000 is $2,500, but the subtraction omits costs and refunds named as absent in S2. The arithmetic does not turn it into profit. Report revenue and spend separately. [S2 Spend, Revenue, Limits]
5. “Search brand 10× and $5 per purchase”: the observed ratios are correct: $2,000 / $200 and $200 / 40. The claim that this proves the best growth opportunity, creative causation or scalability is not supported. [S1 lines 2–3; S2 Limits]
6. “Social is wasting budget”: 1.67× is a rounded attributed-revenue ratio, not a profit or incrementality test. The file cannot establish whether pausing it helps. [S1 line 4; S2 Limits]
7. “Double the budget, pause Social, publish”: exceeds the supplied draft-only boundary. Replace it with a proposed investigation, its human owner and the evidence needed before a real decision. [S2 Permission]
8. “A second AI agrees”: agreement is not a source. The reviewer must show calculations and claim-level evidence; a person checks the final artifact. [S2 Permission; working-brief.md]

Calculation ledger
Search brand, S1 lines 2–3: spend 200; impressions 10,000; clicks 500; purchases 40; revenue 2,000. CTR 5.00%; CPC 0.40; CVR 8.00%; CPA 5.00; ROAS 10.00×.
Social prospecting, S1 line 4: spend 600; impressions 80,000; clicks 800; purchases 20; revenue 1,000. CTR 1.00%; CPC 0.75; CVR 2.50%; CPA 30.00; ROAS 1.67×.
Email event, S1 line 5: spend 200; impressions 10,000; clicks 200; purchases 10; revenue 500. CTR 2.00%; CPC 1.00; CVR 5.00%; CPA 20.00; ROAS 2.50×.
All campaigns: spend 1,000; impressions 100,000; clicks 1,500; purchases 70; revenue 3,500. CTR 1.50%; CPC 0.67; CVR 4.67%; CPA 14.29; ROAS 3.50×.

The reference is one defensible brief, not the only acceptable wording. Accept a different next investigation if its reasoning follows the sources and stays within permission.
